Then there’s Laura Secord Chocolates based in Ontario, which uses blueberry, strawberry, and banana flavors for its Super Kid ice cream.In Wisconsin, Cedar Crest Ice Cream makes Super Madness with blue raspberry, cherry, and vanilla flavors.Ohio-based United Dairy Farmers, for example, creates Super Moo with a combination of blue vanilla, cherry, and vanilla.In other Midwestern states, the Superman ice cream flavors vary a little more: Superman Ice Cream at the Minow Bucket Superman Ice Cream in Other States & Canada Nevertheless, it’s a popular flavor alone and as part of Superman ice cream. Many people have tried to replicate the original Blue Moon recipe, and although some have come close, the true formula remains a secret. Speculators say that they can taste a range of flavors - marshmallows, almond extract, citrus notes, and cereals such as Fruit Loops, Fruity Pebbles, and Trix.Īccording to patent ownership, Austrian chemist Bill “Doc” Sidon created the formula while working as the chief flavor chemist at Petran Products in Milwaukee in the 1950s. The bright blue color is where it gets its name, but the proprietary blend remains under lock and key. No one really knows the flavor of Blue Moon ice cream. Superman Ice Cream | photo via The Blue Moon Ice Cream Flavor Mystery